3
B-CELL MONOCLONAL LYMPHOCYTOSIS
IN THREE INDIVIDUALS LIVING
NEAR A HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE
GE MARTI, J MULLER, M STETLER-STEVENSON,
AND N CAPORASO
ABSTRACT
The blood from three ATSDR study participants initially identified
by CDC as having abnormal B-cell patterns was redrawn and analyzed at CBER
FDA. A B-cell monoclonal lymphocytosis (BCML) with differing surface immunophenotypes
was confirmed in all three cases even though the complete blood counts
(CBC) were normal. Cell cycle analysis showed that there was an increase
in G2M B-cells. A review of blood films revealed that each participant
had a differing lymphocyte morphology. The first individual (CDC Case Number
11, see Chapters 1 and 2) had a typical small B-cell chronic lymphocytic
leukemia (B-CLL) with the presence of smudge cells. The second individual
(CDC Case Number 7) appeared to have an atypical variant of B-CLL with
NK (natural killer) marker expression. The third individual (CDC Case Number
9 had some lymphocytes with plasmacytoid features consistent with Waldenstrom's
disease. Morphometric analysis of the size, mean density, density variability
and shape of lymphocyte nuclei showed significant differences in the mean
values for each individual. There was an inverse relationship between nuclear
area and density for all subjects; however, values for each individual
occupied a unique range along a common continuum. These initial findings
stress the importance of cytomorphology in the differential diagnosis of
a BCML. Its relevance to clinical presentation, management and prognosis
is unknown at this time. Although all these subjects showed unique characteristics,
they may represent a continuum of the same lymphoproliferative disease
(LPD) which over time could develop into specific, clinically, recognizable
LPD. These findings also suggest that the incidence of B-CLL may be higher
than currently realized, and that environmental exposure to organic solvents
needs to be further explored as a risk factor for this family of LPD.
The incidence of BCML in an adult reference population remains to be determined.
INTRODUCTION
During the past two years in collaboration with
the CDC, we have discovered several individuals in apparently good health
with a B-CLL like immunophenotype. Initially we noted isolated cases
of increased B-cells or a CD5+ B-cell lymphocytosis. Review of the
blood film and CBC revealed a slight lymphocytosis. From these single
isolated findings, we had an opportunity to restudy three individuals.
This is a report of that study.
METHODS AND MATERIALS
Blood Films
Unstained blood films were prepared in the field
and fresh blood in heparin was redrawn and sent by overnight mail to CBER,
FDA. The blood films were stained in the Hematology Laboratory, Clinical
Center, NIH and stained blood films were then photomicrographed using a
100x oil objective and Kodak slide film (ASA 40). An attempt was made to
photograph as many lymphocytes as possible from a single blood film. The
slide film was developed commercially and transferred (digitized) to a
Kodak Photo CD. Adobe Photoshop was used to prepare a composite (gallery
or catalogue) of the individual lymphocytes.
Image Analysis
NIH Image, v. 1.58 was used to process and analyze
the composite images. This program was created by Wayne Rasband, NCI, NIH
and is available as freeware by anonymous FTP from ftp://zippy.nimh.nih.gov.
After digitization, the area, mean, maximum and minimum densities, perimeter,
and major and minor axes were measured for each lymphocyte nucleus. The
number
of cells analyzed from each slide was 66, 66 and 76 respectively.
Flow Cytometry
An aliquot of the heparinized blood was washed,
cytoshed for 40 min at 37° C and stained with the following panel of
reagents: unstained cells, Simultest reagents, isotype control, Leucogate,
CD3/CD19, CD4/CD8, NK cells CD3/CD16/CD56, CD19/CD5, CD20/CD5, and CD20/CD23
(All are from BDIS.). The kappa-lambda analysis consisted of three sets
of reagents: CD19 (B4 RD1, Coulter) and B-cell kappa FITC marker and CD19
(B4 PE) and B-cell lambda marker FITC from Ortho Diagnostic Systems, Inc.
(Raritan, NJ). Simultest anti-kappa FITC and anti-lambda PE to which
was added CD19 (Leu 12 PerCP) were all from BDIS. Anti-kappa R-PE, anti-lambda
FITC, and CD19 TriColor were obtained from Caltag (Burlingame, CA). It
should be noted that in the two three color analyses the flurochromes are
switched on the kappa and lambda reagents. Whole blood lysis was carried
out after a 30 minute incubation in the cold using FACSLyse. After washing
twice, they were fixed and resuspended in 0.5 ml of 0.5% buffered paraformaldehyde.
A FACScan flow cytometer using Cellquest software was used to acquire and
analyze 20,000 events. In the three color analysis, scatter and the third
color CD19 PerCP (FL3) was used for gating on B-cells. FACSComp and Calabrite
beads (BDIS) were used to standardize the setup of the instrument. For
cell cycle analysis, hypaque ficoll cell suspensions (1 x 10 6 cells per
ml final concentration) were stained with the FITC conjugated anti-CD20
(B1, Coulter) or anti HLA-DR FITC reagent (BDIS), fixed in 70% ETOH and
then stained with propidium iodine (PI). At the time of analysis, the ethanol
fixed cells are incubated with PI (50 mg/ml) and ribonuclease (1 mg per
ml) for 30 min at 37°C and analyzed immediately on a FACScan flow cytometer
using CELLFIT software for both the acquisition and analysis of 20,000
events. Modfit LT was also used. FDAplot was used to prepare composite
displays.
RESULTS
Image Analysis
Figure 1 shows a representative selection of lymphocytes
from digitized images of subjects’ blood films. A summary of the morphometric
data obtained for each individual is given in Table 1. This data shows
that the mean values of each of the measured parameters are different for
each subject. Moreover, when the data is arranged in the order CDC Case
Numbers 9, 7, 11, several strong trends are evident: nuclear area decreases,
nuclear density increases, variability in nuclear density decreases, the
ratio of major to minor axes decreases. This confirms the morphological
review of the blood films that indicates a trend to smaller, rounder, more
uniformly dense lymphocytes in Case Number 11 compared to Case Number 9.
Plots of nuclear area and density for each nucleus (Figure 2) showed an
inverse relationship for lymphocytes in all three individuals. However
values for each subject occupied a different range along a continuum.
Flow Cytometry
A composite of the immunophenotyping results for
each individual are show in Figures 3, 4 and 5. The absolute lymphocyte
count for these three individuals was less than 5000 cells per ml. They
all had 23% to 30% B-cells implying 1150 to 1500 B-cells per ml. The percent
kappa-positive cells were 79%, 88% and 93% with kappa/lambda ratios of
8.1, 12.1 and 40.5 respectively. Under the best of circumstances,
this would mean that one in four or one in three cells is a B-cell and
there is an even higher chance that the B-cell is monoclonal. In all three
individuals the larger cells, particularly the ones with granules, can
be disregarded as NK cells. In all three individuals a population of normal
B-cells remain. This is quite evident in case numbers 7 and 11. It should
also be noted that case 11 is the most B-CLL like in that the CD20 CD5
clone shows a decrease in fluorescence intensity for CD20 expression.
This is classical for B-CLL whereas case 7 shows a distinct CD20 CD5 clone,
the CD20 fluorescence intensity is not yet decreased. Cases 7 and 11 both
show expression of CD23, while it is absent in case 9. In addition, case
9 does not show the same pattern for CD5 expression. Thus in conclusion,
the immunophenotypes are distinctly different for each subject.
The cell cycle analysis is summarized in Figure 6 and
Table 2. In Figure 6 the data on these three individuals is summarized
in multiple two parameter contour and dot plots and single parameter DNA
histograms. We wish to draw attention to an increase in G2M cells best
seen in the dotplots and suggested in the single parameter DNA histograms
and contour plots. This is usually not seen in normal peripheral blood
lymphocytes and is usually not seen in B-CLL samples unless a large number
of cells are analyzed using a wide gate. The increased G2M cells appear
to be in the CD20 positive population. For these individuals, the
S + G2M CD20 positive cells are 6.8%, 6.8%, and 6.9% respectively. The
number of HLA-DR positive cells tended to be lower compared to the CD20
data; however, Case Number 11 shows 10% S + G2M HLA-DR positive cells.
DISCUSSION
In this study, we found three individuals with a
BCML with differing or variable immunophenotypes, associated with evidence
of increased G2M CD20 positive cells. All three had varying lymphocyte
morphology by light microscopy which was confirmed by morphometric analysis.
The difficulties encountered in the technical determination of a kappa
lambda analysis have been raised and discussed elsewhere (1). Ironically
the B lymphocytes of these individuals would make excellent positive controls
for these reagents. In addition to the kappa/lambda analysis, the CD5/CD20
or CD5/CD19 pattern of expression constitutes a characteristic pattern
of normal remnant T cells when B-cells predominate. Residual normal B-cells
are seen when the lymphocytosis is not very large. The characteristic signature
of a CD5 positive B-cell clone
is well known. In an earlier report we suggested a progression from
a negative CD5 BCML, to a CD5 CD20 bright BCML to a CD5 CD20 dim BCML (2-4).
We see this same exact progression in these three individuals and it seems
to parallel their ages. This suggests the need for longitudinal and cross
sectional studies.
The finding of increased G2M cells is not totally
unexpected. Aneuploidy is rarely seen flow cytometrically in B-CLL and
is probably limited by the number of channels used for detection but this
has not been formally tested. Based on our experience, the use of
2048 channels might be expected to resolve some of the subtle cytogentic
translocations including trisomy 12. And in B-CLL if the gates are
set wide enough, large B-cells show not only increased G2M cells but some
are probably CD10 positive (2). It is suspected that in early preclinical
B-CLL, it is easier to find G2M cells because they are not diluted out
by the clone.
While the measured, morphological parameters also suggest
a progression and a shift in the lymphocyte profile, the exact role of
morphometric analysis remains to be discerned. More data needs to be accumulated
to determine the usefulness of such numerical data. We envision that the
combination of flow cytometric analysis and sorting, morphometric analysis
and molecular markers will permit us to discern not only the early events
of LPD but differences between closely related LPD.
The first and foremost question raised by these
findings is what is the incidence of a BCML with or without CD5 expression
in a normal adult population? In the study of Jack et. al. (Chap.
10), approximately 1000 samples sent for routine blood counts in patients
over the age of 40 years who had no clinical reason to suspect a hematological
malignancy were screened. At least 1.7% had evidence of a clonal B-cell
population using an IgH PCR assay and most of these patients were found
to have a B-CLL phenotype by flow cytometry. It is also common for
clinical flow cytometry laboratories to find B-CLL clones in normal donors
or in patients with slightly raised or normal absolute lymphocyte counts
(personal observation). However, the frequency of this observation is unknown.
Of interest, Liu et al., using a nested PCR assay showed that the incidence
of BCL2 translocations in both blood and spleen are 55% and 35% respectively
and increase with age (5). BCL2 translocations occur predominantly in follicular
lymphomas and is thought to be a major step in the lymphomagenesis of this
particular B-NHL. This incidence of BCL2 mutations is higher than the lifetime
risk of NHL. Therefore other events must be required for the full expression
of this lymphoma. There are earlier reports showing a similar phenomenon
in tonsils (6, 7). A similar situation would probably exist for a BCML.
In fact these two assays should probably be combined along with other markers
of human lymphoproliferative disease such as cyclin D1/PRAD in future studies
of BCML.
A second question concerns the natural history of
a BCML. There are essentially three possibilities. It is transient and
will disappear; remain stable or progress to a clinically recognizable
LPD. Given the increase incidence in NHL over the last decade and an aging
population, the presence of a BCML may be an important predisposing factor.
A third question concerns the differential diagnosis.
At first glance, this concern may seem artificial, academic and trivial.
At this point a CD5+ BCML is a finding and not a diagnosis. It could be
the cellular equivalent of a monoclonal gammopathy of unknown significance
(MGUS). There is certainly no harm to be done in reviewing the blood film
and attempting to correlate the flow cytometric data. In fact, flow cytometry
is becoming an useful adjunct for the differential diagnosis of closely
related chronic lymphoid leukemia and low grade lymphomas. Unfortunately
we do not yet have the tools to predict which BCML will progress to a clinically
recognizable LPD. In fact we do not even have an assay to predict which
Rai Stage 0 or I or Binet Stage A or B, B-CLL patients will progress to
an advanced clinical stage.
Related to the natural history and the differential
diagnosis of a BCML is what to tell patients and their families. Faguet
et al., have described and followed 28 patients with early or pre clinical
B-CLL (8). Over a five year period at least 8 of these patients have progressed
to overt B-CLL. They were followed annually with CBCs and microscopic surface
immunofluoresence. It seems reasonable to anticipate that at least some
individuals with BCML will progress. However early B-CLL can be an indolent
disease and in the absence of therapy these patients can have a normal
life span (9). A benign monoclonal lymphocytosis has also been recognized
(10, 11). Follow up of these individuals should probably be no different
than for patients with early or pre-clinical B-CLL. Reassurance and an
interval CBC will suffice in the majority of individuals. A flow cytometric
analysis of lymphocyte subsets with or without a PCR based assay for monoclonality
should probably be carried out in an investigative protocol setting. A
CT scan would be expected to non revealing while a bone marrow biopsy and
aspirate should be considered invasive at this stage. If the latter is
done, the biopsy should be done in conjunction with an immunperoxidase
assay to aid in the detection of an early interstitial B-cell infiltrate.
Also the aspirate should be submitted for the flow cytometric analysis
of lymphocyte subsets and a kappa lambda analysis.
There is one clinical setting where these considerations
might assume greater significance. Familial B-CLL is defined as two or
more first degree relatives with the disease. Quite often two or more siblings
or two generations will have the disease. Unaffected family members from
B-CLL kindred’s might benefit from these assays in terms of an early diagnosis.
But at this time there would still be no way of predicting if an early
diagnosis in such a family member would progress to overt B-CLL. This remains
experimental, requires clinical correlation and is best carried out in
an investigative protocol with the availability of genetic counseling unless
the testing is done anonymously.
In conclusion, pilot studies have been described
in three individuals with BCML. Before a causal association with environmental
exposure to organic solvents can be made, the incidence of BCML in a normal
adult reference population is needed. Such a study should combine flow
cytometry with a PCR based assay of monoclonality and other markers associated
with LPD. Protocols to investigate family members should include these
assays in order to characterize their significance regarding risk. If testing
is not done anonymously, some provision for genetic counseling and future
follow up would be necessary. Regardless of the course taken, these finding
suggest that we may be getting closer to the underlying molecular and cellular
lesions of the most common LPD in aged people: B-CLL and low grade B-NHL.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The technical expertise of PA Carter, GC Washington,
F Abassi, V Zenger and D Cragg are gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES
1. Marti GE. Quantitative flow cytometry (QFCM) in B-chronic lymphocytic
leukemia (B-CLL).
Clin Immunol Newsletter 15: 1995.
2. Marti GE, Faguet GB, Stewart C, Branham P, Carter PH, Washington
GC, et al., Evolution
of leukemic heterogeneity of human B-CLL lymphocytes between
and within patients. Curr
Top Microbiol Immunol 1992; 182:303-11.
3. Marti GE, Faguet G, Bertin P, Agee J, Washington G, Ruiz S, et al.,
CD20 and CD5
expression in B chronic lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL).
Proc NY Acad Sci USA 1992;
651:480.
4. Marti GE. An edited transcription of an oral presentation in Mechanisms
of B cell neoplasia.
In: Potter M, Melchers F, eds. Basel:Editiones Roche
1995; 129-36.
5. Liu Y, Hernandez AM, Shibata D, Cortopassi GA. BCL2 translocation
frequency rises with
age in humans. PNAS 1994; 8910-14.
6. Limpens J, de Jong D, van Kreiken JHM, Price CGA, Young BD, van
Ommen GB, and
Kluin PM. Bcl-2/JH rearrangements in benign lymphoid
tissues with follicular hyperplasia.
Oncogene 1991; 6:2271-76.
7. Aster JC, Kobayashi Y, Shiota M, Mori S, Sklar J. Am J Pathol 1992;
141:291-99.
8. Faguet GB, Agee JF, Marti GE. Clone emergence and evolution in chronic
lymphocytic
leukemia: characterization of clinical, laboratory
and immunophenotypic profiles of 25 patients.
Leukemia and Lymphoma 1992; 6:345-56.
9. Rozman C and Montserrat E. Chronic lymphocytic leukemia current
concepts. NEJM 1996;
333:1052-53.
10. Han T, Ozer H, Gavigan M, Gajera R, Minowada J, Bloom ML, et al.,
Benign monoclonal
B-cell lymphocytosis - a benign variant
of CLL: clinical, immunologic, phenotypic, and
cytogenetic studies in 20 patients.
Blood 1984; 64(1):244-52.
11. Bassan R, Buzzetti M, Marini B, Rambaldi A, Allavena P, Barbui
T. Investigation of chronic
lymphocytosis in adults. Am J Clin Pathol
1988; 89:783-87.
Return To Contents