Best concentration of formaldehyde responses

From: Lorrie Epling (lepling@medsfgh.ucsf.edu)
Date: Sun Feb 24 2002 - 19:56:20 EST


Thanks to all that responded to the following query:

>Dear Purdue site:
>
>Currently we use a 1:4 dilution of methanol free, EM grade, 10%
>formalin in PBS as a fixative for immunophenotyping of human blood.
>We have some preliminary evidence that this concentration is
>contributing to a decrease in fluorescence for CD45RA Fitc when
>analyzed at 24 hours.
>
>A literature review indicates this is a stronger concentration than
>the norm (0.5, 1.0 or 2%).  Our specimens are processed with either
>FACS Lysis or Coulter Immunoprep, then fixed.  Any opinions or
>suggestions concerning what concentration best preserves as well as
>inactivates viral components?


In summary, 1 to 2% paraformaldehyde or formaldehyde works well for
routine CD4/CD8 immunophenotyping and is recommended by the CDC.
Many other antigens hold up well with these concentrations.  However
CD45RA, used in analysis of naive T cell subsets,  decreases in
fluorescence over a 24 hour period and lower concentrations of
fixative are necessary for this, and possibly other less commonly
used, antigens.


Results from the literature:

MMWR, May 08,1992/41 (RR-8);001: Guidelines for the Performance of
CD4+ T Cell determinations in persons with Human Immunodeficiency
Virus Infection, pg 6 of 16:
iii.  Incubate all tubes in the dark during the immunophenotyping
procedure.  j.  Before analysis on the flow cytometer, fix all sample
tubes after staining and lysing with 1%-2% buffered paraformaldehyde
or formaldehyde.  (This should be done even if the commercial
lysing/fixing reagents contain a fixative).

"Utility of formaldehyde fixation for flow cytometry and inactivation
of the AIDS associated retrovirus." J Immunol Methods, 1986, Jan
22;86(1) 143-9, Lifson JD, Sasaki DT, Engleman EG.  We found that
both formaldehyde (0.37% v/v) and paraformaldehyde 0.5% w/v)
completely inactivated the infectious activity of both free and
cell-associated lymphadenopathy associated virus.

"Effects of cellular fixatives on human immunodeficiency virus
production." Cytometry. 1990;11(5):647-51, Cory JM, Rapp F,
Ohlsson-Wilhelm BM.  Thirty minute fixation with formaldehyde
(1.85%), methanol (absolute), methanol:acetone (1:1), or
paraformaldehde (0.5%) reduced the infectivity of HIV-1 infected H9
cells by greater than 99.99%.

Responses from the "flowers":

From: "Donnenberg, Albert" <donnenbergad@MSX.UPMC.EDU>
Date: Sat, 16 Feb 2002 17:00:41 -0500

We made the same observation some years ago.  Of dozens of
specificities tested, CD45RA was the only one affected in this
concentration range.  We now routinely use a final concentration
0.25% methanol-free formaldehyde. This is sufficient to fix the cells
(but just barely).
Albert Donnenberg
University of Pittsburgh

If you are using the FACS Lyse from BD, it has formaldehyde in it.
This already fixes the cells, so I would recommend a very low
concentration (<1%) of a final step paraformaldehyde fix.

Randy T. Fischer
NIH/NIAMS
Building 10, Room 6D57
9000 Rockville Pike
Bethesda, MD 20892
(301) 594-3537
fischer1@mail.nih.gov

From: "Mark Kukuruga" <kukuru@med.umich.edu>

It's not so much the concentration as . . .
Both Immunoprep (the kit?) and FACS Lysing Solution include a
fixative.  Therefore, you're fixing your samples twice.  The
consequence of this could be reduction in fluorescence, or more
likely an increase in background noise - - either way, you lose
resolution.
MAK.

From: "Simon Monard" <smonard@trudeauinstitute.org>

The cells are fixed after FACS Lysis treatment, you could use a lower
concentration of formaldehyde, 0.5 or 1%. You can also wash the
fixative out after an hour or two and suspend your cells in PBS, the
cells will remain in pretty good shape for a few days or longer.
Often after formaldehyde fixation the autofluorescence of all cells
increases gradually, washing the fixative out prevents this.

Simon Monard
FACS Lab Manager
Trudeau Institute
Saranac Lake
NY12983

Thanks for these and other responses along the same lines.

Sincerely,
Lorrie Epling



This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Wed Apr 03 2002 - 11:59:25 EST